Skip to content

Woman delivers an innacAccurate newborn

Inadvertent error at an Australian IVF clinic leads to a woman birthing another couple's child.

Mother delivers non-existent infant
Mother delivers non-existent infant

Woman delivers an innacAccurate newborn

In a shocking turn of events, the Monash-IVF clinic in Melbourne, Australia, has agreed to pay AUD 56 million (EUR 31.2 million) in an out-of-court settlement, without admitting guilt, to avoid a lawsuit alleging the wrongful destruction of viable embryos due to a faulty genetic test.

The investigation revealed that an embryo intended for another patient had been mistakenly thawed and implanted into the wrong woman. The human error at the clinic resulted in an embryo from one couple being implanted into the wrong woman. The affected woman, whose name remains undisclosed, unknowingly carried another couple's child.

Upon checking, staff found more embryos than expected, which led to an investigation. The mix-up at the Monash-IVF clinic in Brisbane, Australia, occurred in February.

The clinic director, Michael Knaap, expressed deep sorrow for the incident. "Everyone at Monash IVF is devastated by the mix-up," he said. The clinic apologised to all those involved and assured the affected patients of support during "these incredibly painful times."

The Queensland Health Department will work with Monash IVF to strengthen safety measures in their Queensland clinics to identify and mitigate any risks. The Australian Social Services Minister, Amanda Rishworth, called for consequences to restore trust in IVF clinics, expressing her personal pain as a mother who had a baby through IVF.

"I cannot imagine the pain the affected families are going through," Rishworth said, emphasising the trust placed in these companies (reproductive medicine clinics). The mix-up was discovered when the parents of the baby asked to have their remaining embryos transferred to another IVF provider.

The Monash-IVF clinic informed the affected patients of the mix-up and offered support within a week, also reporting the incident to the relevant authorities. The clinic has assured the public that they are taking all necessary steps to prevent such incidents in the future.

Read also: