Unveiling the right to observe: a look at unhindered visibility

In the Opinion section of a popular monthly online publication, John R. MacArthur, editor of Harper's Magazine, discusses the importance of freedom of expression in the arts.

MacArthur argues against the suppression of the film "J'accuse," directed by Roman Polanski, which was recently screened in the anglophone world. The film, a historically faithful account of Alfred Dreyfus's victimization and rescue, was initially released in France in 2019 but has only recently been shown to English-speaking audiences.

The columnist criticises the act of denying the general public access to a book or film to appease prejudices, stating it as a violation of freedom of expression. MacArthur's stance is clear: everyone should have the right to see and read, regardless of external pressures.

MacArthur's column also touches upon the Dreyfus Affair's impact on Theodor Herzl, a journalist who wrote a pamphlet titled "The Jewish State" in 1896, often cited as a significant influence on the creation of the State of Israel. Historian Derek Penslar suggests that Herzl initially showed indifference towards the Dreyfus Affair but later claimed that it made him a Zionist.

In a separate matter, the columnist comments on the political landscape in Quebec. François Legault, the province's premier, has been criticising his transport ministers for not asking enough questions about the costs of SAAQclic. Legault himself claimed he did not know about the costs before February 2025.

The columnist maintains a commitment to diversity of voices and ideas, as well as avoiding repetition in their writing. However, it is important to note that the opinions expressed in the column reflect the author's views, not necessarily those of Le Devoir.

Unfortunately, the column is published on a monthly basis, and some unfortunate news has emerged within the publication. Both the general manager of Publications BLD and magazine editor Isabelle Vaillancourt have passed away. Their contributions to the publication will be deeply missed.

As for suggested reading, MacArthur recommends "Her," a film by Spike Jonze, and sociologist Étienne Guertin-Tardif's writings on the same film. The column serves as a thought-provoking read, encouraging readers to reflect on the importance of freedom of expression in the arts and the political landscape.