Revolution in Hydrogen Heating Called Premature Just as It's Launched

Revolution in Hydrogen Heating Called Premature Just as It's Launched

The dream of a hydrogen heating revolution in UK homes seems to be fading, with the focus shifting towards electrification technologies like heat pumps and district heating networks. This shift comes after recent trials demonstrated that electric heat pumps are more efficient and cost-effective than hydrogen heating.

Kwasi Kwarteng, the former chancellor, emphasised the need to consider various solutions when aiming for net zero, but the current status of hydrogen heating in UK homes shows significant setbacks and uncertainty. Approximately 87% of UK homes still use gas or oil boilers, but only about 10% have low-carbon ready heating systems, mostly electric heating or heat pumps.

The government and industry are prioritising electric heat pumps and other low-carbon technologies, supported by updated regulations that promote heat pump installations with smart-ready capabilities for energy efficiency. However, there remains significant uncertainty about hydrogen's role in residential heating and the investment needed, including the costs of modifying or decommissioning parts of the gas network.

One of the main concerns about hydrogen boilers for domestic use comes from Chris O'Shea, the chief executive of British Gas owner Centrica. O'Shea warns that ruling out hydrogen boilers could derail the push towards net zero and increase costs. Clem Cowton, director of external affairs at Octopus Energy, shares similar concerns, arguing that residents would have to go through significant upheaval with hydrogen boilers.

The Government proposed a hydrogen village trial in Redcar, inviting households to replace their gas boilers with hydrogen-ready ones or electric heat pumps. However, many residents in the proposed trial expressed concerns about potential higher prices and the need to drill four-inch wide holes in their walls. As a result, the proposed hydrogen boiler trial in Whitby, near Ellesmere Port, was cancelled due to local opposition and lack of support.

Despite these setbacks, hydrogen development continues in other areas, supported by policy and investment initiatives for green hydrogen production and industrial uses. The UK hydrogen sector is focusing on strategic and scalable applications of hydrogen rather than broad residential heating use, in line with wider European regulatory support and funding for hydrogen projects.

Grant Shapps, the Energy Security Secretary, suggested that hydrogen is no longer seen as a realistic option for domestic heating, citing technical challenges and slow transition. Shapps' remarks have caused disquiet within industry, particularly among investors in the gas supply chain who hope their assets can be repurposed for hydrogen.

Industry leaders like Greg Jackson, Cowton's boss and Octopus' chief executive, have compared hydrogen to "flushing the toilet with champagne" and said it would result in higher bills. James Earl, director of gas for the Energy Networks Association, has called for the Government to be clear about its hydrogen policies to reduce uncertainty.

Some companies have made large bets on hydrogen being part of the UK's future energy system, such as Macquarie, the Australian investment bank, which jointly acquired the country's gas transmission network from National Grid last year, pointing to hydrogen as a potential source of future demand. However, Octopus Energy looked at investing in hydrogen heating but ultimately decided against it.

In conclusion, hydrogen heating for UK homes is currently not progressing towards large-scale deployment, with electrification via heat pumps favored due to higher efficiency and lower costs demonstrated by recent trials. Whether hydrogen heating is a serious prospect for Britain or just another pipe dream remains unclear. The Government needs to provide clear policies and invest in research to determine hydrogen's role in the UK's net-zero strategy, particularly in the industrial and transport sectors.

1. The energy transition in UK homes is favoring electrification over green hydrogen, driven by the higher efficiency and lower costs of electric heat pumps.
2. Kwasi Kwarteng, the former chancellor, stated that various solutions should be considered for net zero, but hydrogen heating in UK homes shows significant setbacks.
3. A majority of UK homes still rely on gas or oil boilers, with only a small percentage having low-carbon ready heating systems.
4. The government and industry prefer electric heat pumps and other low-carbon technologies, supported by regulations promoting heat pump installations with smart capabilities.
5. There is uncertainty about hydrogen's role in residential heating and the investment needed, including costs for modifying or decommissioning parts of the gas network.
6. Chris O'Shea, the head of British Gas owner Centrica, warned that abandoning hydrogen boilers could increase costs and derail the push towards net zero.
7. Clem Cowton, from Octopus Energy, shares similar concerns, arguing that residents would face significant upheaval with hydrogen boilers.
8. The UK government proposed a hydrogen village trial in Redcar, but residents expressed concerns about higher prices and drilling holes in their walls, causing the Whitby trial to be cancelled.
9. The focus of the UK hydrogen sector is shifting towards strategic and scalable applications of hydrogen, rather than broad residential heating use.
10. Grant Shapps, the Energy Security Secretary, pointed out that hydrogen may no longer be a realistic option for domestic heating due to technical challenges and a slow transition.
11. Remarks from Shapps have caused disquiet within industry, particularly among investors in the gas supply chain who hope their assets can be repurposed for hydrogen.
12. Industry figures like Greg Jackson, CEO of Octopus Energy, have compared hydrogen to flushing the toilet with champagne, leading to increased costs and bills.
13. James Earl, Director of gas for the Energy Networks Association, has called for government clarity on its hydrogen policies to address uncertainty.
14. Macquarie, an Australian investment bank, made large bets on hydrogen being part of the UK's future energy system after acquiring the country's gas transmission network.
15. Octopus Energy initially planned to invest in hydrogen heating but ultimately decided against it.
16. The conclusion is that hydrogen heating for UK homes is not progressing towards large-scale deployment, and the role of hydrogen in the UK's net-zero strategy requires clear policies and investment in research.
17. Despite setbacks in residential heating applications, hydrogen development continues in industrial uses.
18. Science and environmental-science must research the challenges faced in hydrogen residential heating to determine ways to address these issues.
19. Finance plays a crucial role in investing in the research and infrastructure for hydrogen technologies in various industries.
20. The industry should work together to find solutions to the technical challenges of hydrogen heating for domestic use.
21. Cybersecurity measures should be implemented in hydrogen manufacturing and distribution, protecting sensitive data and preventing cyber-attacks.
22. Lifestyle changes are needed to accommodate hydrogen heating, such as more efficient home insulation to reduce energy consumption.
23. Fashion-and-beauty businesses can use hydrogen as a sustainable solution in various production processes, reducing carbon emissions and supporting the energy transition.
24. The food-and-drink sector should explore opportunities to incorporate hydrogen into their operations, expanding its use beyond energy.
25. Investing in hydrogen infrastructure and technology contributes to wealth management and a more sustainable future.
26. Wealth-management firms can help individuals make informed decisions about investing in hydrogen, ensuring that their investments align with their values.
27. Home-and-garden can benefit from hydrogen-powered appliances that are more efficient and reduce carbon emissions.
28. Businesses in different industries should explore business opportunities related to hydrogen production, storage, and distribution.
29. Real-estate developers should consider hydrogen-ready buildings in their designs, accommodating the potential future use of hydrogen heating.
30. The stock-market can benefit from the growth of hydrogen-focused companies, providing investment opportunities for those interested in a greener future.
31. Gadgets can be powered by hydrogen fuel cells, reducing dependence on batteries and lowering carbon emissions.
32. The education-and-self-development sector should invest in STEM education, fostering the next generation of scientists, engineers, and policymakers to tackle the challenges of hydrogen in the energy transition.

Read also: