Skip to content

Michael Andrick's query: What's the reason behind the minimal discussions regarding this particular book?

Unspoken yet crucial insights offered by Rainer Mausfeld's 'Disenchantment of Power' expose the veil behind Western politics, shedding light on the discrepancy between appearances and reality. Perhaps the reason for its limited discourse stems from this very revelation?

Michael Andrick debates the reason for minimal discussions surrounding a specific book
Michael Andrick debates the reason for minimal discussions surrounding a specific book

Michael Andrick's query: What's the reason behind the minimal discussions regarding this particular book?

In the realm of political discourse, a new book by Rainer Mausfeld, titled "Hybris and Nemesis," is stirring conversations about the intricate workings of power and democracy. The book, set for release in 2023, has already received positive remarks in discussions about political and media influence on society, including noted commentary in Overton Magazin and NachDenkSeiten.

Mausfeld's work delves into the historical evolution of power dynamics, offering insights into the emergence and balancing of power and counter-power. According to the book, agriculture, livestock farming, and storage have opened up new avenues for "parasitic elites" to appropriate part of the yield of others' work. This concept is not foreign to ancient societies, as evidenced by the example of hunter-gatherer tribes, where success in hunting was often attributed to the manufacturer of the deadly arrowhead.

The book also sheds light on the challenges of creating a counter-power to corrupted power or property elites in the modern nation-state. It argues that representative democracy, with a capitalist economic system, is dependent on "ideological power" and targeted manipulation of the population's perception. This assertion is supported by the observation that representative democracy, as Mausfeld explains, was introduced to maintain an oligarchy in power through elections.

Historically, the emergence of greater freedom for the non-wealthy has often been marked by a "blood trail" of brutal power struggles. This was evident in ancient Athens, where Solon divided Attica into 139 demes, abolished debt slavery, and established the Council of Four Hundred for the lowest property class. Kleisthenes expanded political participation and ensured extensive freedom of speech in the randomly selected Assembly. However, even in Athenian democracy, elections played a subordinate role due to the unequal chances for normal citizens compared to the rich.

Interestingly, Athenian democracy was rejected in the constitutional convention of 1787 in the United States, and the government was designed to protect the wealthy. This highlights the enduring influence of power elites in shaping political systems.

In early kingdoms of Mesopotamia, a plurality of power forms was normal, and "group-centered decision-making processes" existed as balancing moments. This contrasts sharply with the modern nation-state, where the advent of this political structure has provided elites with the perfect institution for "protection rackets."

Pericles formed a structure in which "the people govern themselves on the basis of political equality of all citizens," although women, resident aliens, and slaves were excluded. This highlights the ongoing struggle for true democratic representation and the need for continuous vigilance against the emergence of power elites.

In conclusion, Mausfeld's book provides a thought-provoking analysis of societal deception and power misuse, offering valuable insights into the nature of politics and the challenges of creating counter-power in the modern nation-state. It is a must-read for jurists, medics, and politicians alike.

Read also: