Choosing between an automatic or manual motorhome: which offers better performance?

Touring Europe in an Automatic Motorhome: A Guide

Exploring the European continent in a motorhome can be an unforgettable experience, and the choice between an automatic or manual motorhome is a matter of personal preference. This article aims to provide a clear overview of the advantages and considerations when choosing an automatic motorhome for your travels.

The Driving Experience

All automatics require a more sensitive approach to the throttle than manual gearboxes. However, modern automatic motorhomes change gears smoothly, similar to automatic cars, making them easier to handle for those new to driving automatics.

Robotised manual gearboxes, such as Fiat's previous automatic gearbox Ducato model, the Comfort-Matic, may need replacement clutches from time to time, but not as frequently as a regular manual gearbox. On the other hand, CVT-equipped vehicles can feel odd to drive as the engine revs are not directly related to the speed of the vehicle.

Maintenance and Cost

Automatic vehicles tend to wear out front brake discs more frequently than manual vehicles. The biggest downside to buying a motorhome or campervan with an automatic gearbox is the initial cost - they are considerably more expensive. However, the reliability of automatic gearboxes is similar to that of manual gearboxes and they should last just as long.

Fuel Efficiency and Safety

Torque converter automatics are gentle on the drivetrain and can shift gears almost imperceptibly. Newer automatic motorhomes with up to 8-speed gearboxes are more fuel-efficient than older models. The safety of having proper gears for engine braking was emphasized, as it proved lifesaving when the brakes failed on the motorhome.

Insurance and Regulations

Insurance companies often deem automatic motorhomes to be a safer risk, so you might get cheaper motorhome insurance. It's important to check the maximum towing limit of an automatic motorhome, as it may be lower than the manual equivalent.

Driving Technique

If it's your first automatic vehicle, it's VERY easy to confuse the brake pedal for the clutch (which isn't there). Learn to drive with just one foot, keeping your other well out of the way to avoid pressing the accelerator and the brake at the same time! Robotised manual gearboxes can require a slightly different driving technique to make sure the ride isn't 'jerky'.

Additional Features

On modern vehicles, you could look at having an automatic clutch pedal fitted. This costs around £2,000 and converts the clutch to be triggered via a button on the gear knob. All automatic gearboxes have some form of kickdown for increased acceleration when needed.

Manual Gear Selection

Manual gear selection is possible in all automatics, which can be useful for controlling speed when descending a steep hill or when a higher gear is needed.

Manufacturers

Major manufacturers offering automatic transmissions for motorhomes include Allison Transmission, ZF Friedrichshafen, Aisin Seiki, and Tremec.

In conclusion, touring Europe in an automatic motorhome can be a smooth and efficient journey, with modern automatics offering a driving experience similar to that of cars. With careful driving and regular maintenance, an automatic motorhome can provide a reliable and enjoyable travel companion for your European adventures.